Brad Scott’s recent departure from Essendon starkly contrasts with his exit from North Melbourne in 2019. Back then, Kangaroos president Ben Buckley described Scott’s decision to leave as “Brad’s offer to step aside is nothing short of selfless and honourable – terms befitting his character,” while Scott expressed optimism about North’s future. However, critics noted that he left the team in disarray, with David King labeling him “There’s nothing but blue sky for North,” Following Scott’s departure, North Melbourne struggled significantly.
Scott was absent from the press conference announcing his exit from the Bombers earlier this week. Observers largely agree that he was never the right choice for the role, feeling somewhat alienated by Essendon fans and players alike. Concerns lingered about the state he left North Melbourne in, and he was often viewed as an outsider.
The committee responsible for his hiring included individuals like former schoolmate Josh Mahoney, who has since exited football, and Andrew Thorburn, who had a notably brief tenure as CEO. Other panel members, Jordan Lewis and Robert Walls, didn’t have a strong affinity for Essendon. Scott faced a daunting task, burdened with the repercussions of earlier management mistakes, amid instability and unclear messaging regarding the club’s direction. His tenure was further complicated by a spate of injuries.
Appearing on Channel Seven last night, Scott spoke articulately, a common trait among coaches after being dismissed. Previously, his statements often carried a tone of defiance, frequently echoing sentiments like “I inherited a mess, it’s not my fault, give me time and space” Now free from corporate constraints, he candidly discussed the ongoing issues of a club that has struggled to recover from the supplements scandal and has been overly eager for quick success.
Some fans see hope in the idea of bringing back James Hird, a figure closely associated with the club’s history. Hird nearly reclaimed the head coach position in September 2022. During a celebratory cruise for trucking mogul Lindsay Fox’s birthday, renowned former coach Kevin Sheedy expressed confidence in Hird’s potential appointment, believing it would mark a return to the club’s former glory. However, upon returning to shore, he learned that Hird had lost out on the role.
Even nearly four years later, Hird’s influence is still felt at Essendon. Few players are as revered by their supporters as he is. Months before missing out on the coaching position, Hird and Sheedy were celebrated figures at Essendon’s 150th-anniversary festivities. Hird made a dramatic entrance at the MCG, linking arms with current players and former legends, evoking a sense of nostalgia for the club’s storied past.
The shadows of history are ever-present at Essendon. They manifest in the sight of Sheedy and former players waving scarves before matches, in boardroom discussions, and in media commentary from ex-players lamenting the current squad’s dedication compared to their own. This was evident during a recent episode of Nine’s Footy Classified when Hird spoke about the vision of restoring Essendon to greatness.
On the brink of the tumultuous 2013 season, Hird sought wisdom from José Mourinho at Real Madrid. He asked, “why can’t this current lot care as much as we did?” The renowned coach replied, “What’s the secret to your success?”
At that moment, Hird was impatient for results, a mindset that nearly led to Essendon’s downfall and deeply affected his personal well-being. Relying on Hird now, as the club seeks to rebuild, would be ill-advised. Having not coached for over a decade and burdened by the legacy of the supplements controversy, the club should consider other promising candidates who could provide fresh perspectives. There is untapped potential within the current roster, and leaning on past glories could hinder their progress.
- This is an extract from our weekly AFL newsletter, From the Pocket. For the complete version, please visit this page and follow the instructions.
